The Dark Knight

dark-knight-poster-rules.jpg
10/10
Pros: 
A truly dark Knight
Mature handling of superhero lore
Performances allow Nolan to push the envelope
Cons: 
It's PG-13, but it really, really wants to be an R
director: 
Christopher Nolan
Year: 
2008
MPAA Rating: 
PG-13
Company: 
Warner Bros.
caps: 
Did You Know?: 
Wired Magazine reported that Christian Bale insisted on performing many of his own stunts, including riding the real Batpod (the bike) that Nolan had built for the film.
Nolan's inspiration for the Joker came largely from the Batman storyline "The Long Halloween," which originally appeared in 1996 and also served as inspiration for "Batman Begins."
The film is dedicated both to Ledger and to Conway Wickliffe, who was killed during filming.
July 18, 2008

As superheroes go, perhaps none have drawn as much cinematic attention as Batman. It’s because of this that each new installment is met with joy but also apprehension. There’s an elemental quality to Batman, the most basic of superheroes. This primal nature has allowed for brilliant experimentation in both comics and in film, and this newest installment is as worthy an addition to the Batman canon as there has ever been.

Christopher Nolan’s “Dark Knight,” the direct sequel to his acclaimed “Batman Begins,” is a film magnificent in its scope and vision. It’s shocking in its ambition, but also in its economy. From the resoundingly strong cast to the purposeful direction, this Batman hardly misses a note. “The Dark Knight” may not be a perfect film, but that is only because no film can every truly be perfect.

Not long after the action of the previous film, Batman has succeeded in his goal of reviving Gotham. But he soon finds that his reward is a new kind of criminal, desperate men with means to push the boundaries. Batman, as a symbol of justice, is himself unyielding and unreasonable. It only stands to reason then, that in his wake would arise enemies themselves willing to pass beyond reason. Through the efforts of Batman the true forces of law and order have strengthened themselves. Citizens of Gotham have been empowered, and they have in turn empowered Jim Gordon and the new district attorney Harvey Dent to continue the fight that Batman began.

These three men, Gordon, Dent, and Batman, form a trinity that seems on the verge of righting a ship that not long ago appeared lost for good. Their strength is put to the test however, when a force of pure chaos—The Joker—steps into the mix with only one goal: to watch the trinity crumble.

If Batman represents cold, unfeeling justice, then the Joker is irrational death and destruction. He steals only so that he may destroy. He lives only so that he may kill. He plays cop against criminal, criminal against cop, and both sides against themselves. The Joker stands diametrically opposed to the Batman, and it is through his very presence that Gotham’s peace unravel just as Batman’s does as well.

Embodied by Heath Ledger, The Joker isn’t so much a character within “The Dark Knight” as he is an axis around which the film spins. Several times the Joker offers explanations for his physical appearance—the scars that give him a perpetual and horrifying grin. Each of these potential explanations is different, proving that all are ultimately unimportant. The Joker’s origins, it turns out, are trivial. He could not exist without the bat, and his existence similarly provides a fuller meaning and context to the existence of Batman. Ledger’s Joker swirls throughout the film, driving the actions of every other character, sometimes with their knowledge, but more often without. It’s Batman’s role to cut through this storm, to neutralize the Joker. One might be surprised to find that it’s not easily said that he succeeds.

Nolan has crafted the rarest of summer films: a true blockbuster that doesn’t shy away from the quiet moments. Instead, "The Dark Knight" lives in these moments, when Alfred, Lucius Fox, Rachel Dawes, Jim Gordon, and even the Joker share stark, silent space with Batman or his more humane alter-ego. And while many theater goers will buy a ticket to witness mayhem, they will find that they get their money’s worth when the violence gives way to dialogue, or even to the seething quiet that Nolan allows to scream forth.

The director was able to pull this off because he had a dedicated, deadly serious group of actors standing with him. Batman, like all superheroes, lives in a world that can never be our own. Gotham, with its 30 million inhabitants, is itself supernatural. But crafted by Nolan, and populated with the likes of Morgan Freeman, Gary Oldman, and Maggie Gyllenhaal, Gotham becomes as real as the streets of your town. And within this realistic world, Christian Bale, Heath Ledger, and Aaron Eckhart are able to explode forth.

Many critics, perhaps taking a cue from Nolan himself, have likened “The Dark Knight” to a gritty, crime film, but that’s true only in as much as Batman is a gritty crime fighter. “The Dark Knight” may at times wear the costume of an “L.A. Confidential” or “The Departed”—just as Gotham may at times feel like a real city—but underneath that facade is pure superhero guts. Where noir archetypes live in the gray area, Batman defines the black. Nolan’s greatest success may have been in channeling this current within Batman lore. In so doing though, he forces a difficult choice on his characters. This choice defines “The Dark Knight,” but it also sets a new standard of excellence and depth for which all subsequent superhero films must strive.

Eric's picture

Whoa

It's the elusive "Jon Schnaars 10 out of 10". I've never seen it in it's natural habitat before!

Going to see a matinee tomorrow, can't frigging wait!

Christine's picture

the first

this is the first review i am reading and i must say it has gotten me super excited. too bad i must wait until next week to see it. hope everyone else enjoys it!

Prisoner Abel's picture

Long Halloween

Jon, I skimmed the review only because I'm trying not to read too much about it before seeing it. But in the "Did you know?" section you mention Batman Begins and the Joker being inspired by the Long Halloween, where did you hear that? I only ask because the first film didn't have anything in common with comic other than a young batman, and the Joker is a very minor character in the series. Have you read the comic? If so, could you elaborate (without spoiling of course)?

"I like it when they lie still like that."

Jon's picture

It was either on the Wiki or

It was either on the Wiki or IMDB pages. I might not have worded it as well as I could have, but my understanding is that Batman Begins came largely from Batman: Year One (which Miller wrote?) and that the Long Halloween is where most of this storyline was drawn from. The feel and the themes though sort of cross-pollinate was what I meant.

Prisoner Abel's picture

Yeah that makes more sense

Long Halloween had a whole subplot about the rise and fall of Harvey Dent so I can see how it would inform the plot for this one.

"I like it when they lie still like that."

Drunken Zombie's picture

When Christian Bale was

When Christian Bale was doing the media rounds for Batman Begins he quoted LONG HALLOWEEN as sort of the feel they were wanting to bring to the reality of Batman. Which as you pointed out it was a Harvey Dent story but it was about them trying to bring down the mob in that one and they used some of that feel for BEGINS. But if anyone hasn't read LONG HALLOWEEN and loved DARK KNIGHT go read it. There was some stuff taken from it for this in so much as it's about the rise and fall of Dent but the film goes about it in a completely different way.
www.drunkenzombie.com

Eric's picture

Read that as well

Can't remember where though. I am by no means a comic book expert at all, but I believe it was in that article that Christine linked to on Wednesday with her "Batgirl" blog.

foodcore's picture

Indeed

I am still getting chills just thinking about certain parts of that movie from last night.

Pete's picture

And I thought Wall-E was the best film of 2008

On another site, there was a review of the Dark knight where the reviewer brought up a Christopher Nolan quote. It was something along the lines that "Heath as the Joker is like the Shark in Jaws". The reviewer went even further to say that The Joker is like the shark in Jaws, only he can follow you up onto land, and he has another set of teeth waiting under the sand.
I thought that quote best summarized one of the strongest parts of this masterpiece. The Joker is terrifying. I know you guys said you aren't necessarily huge comic fans (excluding Casey) but I am, and the Joker in this film was better than any version I have seen on screen, in a cartoon or in a comic.
He could strike at any point, which makes this film not so far a stretch to review on your site, since the Joker instills more fear in this film than any sort of on screen killers I have seen in a long time.
I could go on and on about this movie. I don't know if you guys are going to go into detail (SPOILER ALERT) about the themes of this movie, and the subtle way the Joker represents terrorists (yes, they do call him a terrorist in the movie) and how Batman is willing to completely invade the private lives of Gotham's citizens just to stop the Joker. That was the least in your face take on the post 9/11 climate I have seen in a film. It probably didn't stand out as much, because of all the other major themes throughout the film.
Oh and (Spoiler once again) What about the fucking number two pencil?

mark's picture

Joker

Obviously, we'll get into this tonight on the podcast, but the portrayal of Joker was scarier to me than most horror villains because there was a point where I actually felt completely hopeless that things weren't going to be ok. I was actually uneasy at the mere though of what was going to happen next, and that's a very very rare thing to come by in a film, especially these days.

Amazonagent's picture

Amazing

That's all i can really say about the movie. It was just amazing. I think you described it perfectly Jon. I can not wait to see this movie again!

**spoiler**

The joker sure knows how to show off a great magic trick! LOL!!!

-Tanya
Believe Again | 7/25/08

Eric's picture

So, comics

After doing the show this week (which should get uploaded tonight sometime), the crew convinced me to try to jump into comics, which is a totally foreign medium to me. So I just ordered "Watchmen" and "The Dark Knight Returns". Should be interesting.

If I end up getting hooked, then I'll definitely have to credit The Dark Knight with opening my eyes to the depth that a superhero story is capable of achieving.

Drunken Zombie's picture

I think you'll enjoy The

I think you'll enjoy The Dark Knight Returns. Watchmen will be a little harder to get into possibly. It's not that you have to know anything going into it. it's a major deconstruction of the comics genre. But it's a good read. Especially if you're curious about the movie. Some other stuff I would recommend would be a book POWERS. It's about cops working in a city loaded with super heroes and they investigate super hero related cases. It's an adult book meaning there's some cussing and nudity. Basically just saying it's not kiddie fluff. But after you read them let me know. Would be interested in your thoughts. And maybe I can throw some more suggestions your way if you get into them.
www.drunkenzombie.com

Drunken Zombie's picture

Oh and if you do like The

Oh and if you do like The Dark Knight Returns then don't expect the same satisfaction out of The Dark Knight Strikes Again. It's a pretty lame follow up. BUT I do also recommend Batman Year One. It was sort of used as a basis for Batman Begins. AND if you like the movie The Dark Knight then I also recommend THE LONG HALLOWEEN. It is the story of Dent's rise and then fall into becoming Two Face. It's more detailed and different from the movie but is a good read as it's about the mob and stuff. Good times. I guess I'm recommending a lot and you haven't even gotten the first ones yet. Hope you like them.
www.drunkenzombie.com

Jon's picture

Powers

I really enjoyed Powers 1&2 (I'm reading them in trade paperback) but Powers 3 was all fucked up. I just think I wasn't properly prepared, because it jumps all over and doesn't follow one main arc throughout the issue. I was checking out the Wiki, and apparently #4 smooths things out a bit. But I was really thrown for a loop.

My new favorite, and something I'd throw out particularly for non-super fans, is Ed Brubaker's "Criminal" series. I've only read the first two, but it is really excellent.

Drunken Zombie's picture

Yeah POWERS got a little

Yeah POWERS got a little weird for a little while. And it does later too. But besides these rare jumps it's pretty consistantly interesting. But of course the Kaotic Chic storyline was just great. Dave has had this idea for awhile for submitting a short film to the contest for Comicon that would basically be COPS set in a POWERS like setting and having nods to all sorts of comic references. One we came up with was having Kaotic Chic spray painted on an alley wall. Just saying POWERS is pretty sweet.
www.drunkenzombie.com

Prisoner Abel's picture

Criminal is amazing. If you

Criminal is amazing. If you like that you should check out 100 Bullets.

"I like it when they lie still like that."

thepuppetmaster's picture

One HELL of a film

I went to a matinee of this on friday the 25th and was BLOWN away!! I knew it was going to be at least entertaining but it was so much more than that. There is actually a message running through the film and by the end I was ready to cheer can't wait to see what Nolan comes up with next, I am sooo there!!